A review is a review is a review .... or is it?
Part 1 of 2
"Realism is a bad word. In a
sense everything is realistic. I see no line between the imaginary and the
real." -- Federico Fellini, movie maker ....
"Anybody can look at a pretty
girl and see a pretty girl. An artist can look at a pretty girl and see the old
woman she will become. A better artist can look at an old woman and see the
pretty girl that she used to be. But a great artist .... can look at an old
woman, portray her exactly as she is .... and force the viewer to see the pretty
girl she used to be .... " -- Robert A. Heinlein, writer ....
As a graduate-student-college-boy,
I took a class on foreign films -- "foreign flicks" -- as we called them, which
included some by Federico Fellini which often have been described as a
blend of fantasy and reality. In this class, we would watch a film one day,
write a review / criticism / critique of it to be turned in at the next class,
which centered on a discussion of the movie we had seen, and then, during a
third classroom day, discuss / argue / debate our written evaluations.
I thoroughly enjoyed the
class, and the two elements which absolutely amazed me were how often we agreed
on elements of the film and how often and widely ranging our disagreements
were. There, you see my logic for multiple reviewers of books and performances --
which will be clarified in Part 2 of this piece.
My memory about these things
was stirred by having recently watched, "La Strada," a 1954 Italian film directed by Fellini. It
translates into "The Road." This is one
Fellini flick I had not seen before. I will not comment on it other than to mention
I think the movie is a minor masterpiece, in the least, (although I hesitate to name a major film masterpiece)
and the casting could not have been better done.
The central characters are
Gelsomina, a young woman played by Giulietta Masina, Fellini's wife; Zampanò, a
brutish, angry man portrayed by Anthony Quinn; and Il Matto, a high wire
performer and clown played by Richard Basehart.
I never have cared for Quinn
simply because he is brutish in appearance and often portrays such creatures in
movie roles -- but, he is a fine actor and between his appearance and his talent
is perfect for this character.
Likewise with Basehart, in an
opposite sense. His appearance is rather wimpish in my eyes, but often he is
inappropriately cast as "hero-type" characters. Il Matto literally and
figuratively is "The Fool," which is why I believe he fits this part well.
Giulietta Masina, I think, is
a bit too old for her part, but the child-like nature of the character and
Masina's extraordinary ability to create expressions perfect for the scenes
make her the centerpiece of the production. Her talent has been compared to
that of Charlie Chaplin.
Might someone else see and interpret this film in different ways? Yes .... absolutely. Even more reason for multiple reviewers. Let us end this now before I
find myself trying to analyze the film characters and the actors playing them, or begin to indulge in
the history of Italian film making.
There are two videos here – one
the soundtrack from the film, "La Strada," composed by Giovanni Rota Rinaldi, an
Italian composer, pianist and conductor working under the name of Nino Rota. He
was a close friend of Fellini. My own thought is that the music sounds better in context with the film, rather than as a stand-alone piece.
Present also is a tribute
piece to Kenneth William David "Ken" Hensley, a guitar and a keyboard man and,
most notably, a composer. He died at age 75 on November 4. Hensley joined the
hard rock band, Uriah Heep, around Christmas 1969 and wrote or co-wrote many of
the group's early songs. He composed "Sunrise" and co-wrote "July Morning" with lead singer, David Garrick, who used the stage name David Byron. I mention those two compositions specifically because they are two of my unconditional
favorites .... eloquent thoughts set to music ....
Happy Thanksgiving .... barring the unforeseen, Part 2 will arrive eventually ....
9 comments:
I've not watched many foreign films which, for me, have always seemed a little too "artsy" for my taste. But as I think we agree, books, films, music... it's all a matter of opinion, making them subjective topics by definition.
I enjoyed your musical selections, even without context of film or lyrics (since I rarely pay attention to lyrics).
That's a fine-looking new bed Buddy has. I'm sad to report we are one dog less at our house. (down to seven) Mabel's time came last week. :(
That is a very very good movie!Thanx! I have saved the full movie and also 8 1/2 and The Sweet life.(i have not seen them)I like alot those old retro movies!I think Quinn plays good!!
Nino Rota's music is beyond heavenly! Ilove them all.Specially the Godfather track an "Once upon a time in America,ups that was Ennio Morricone!
I remember Quinn as playing cowboy in different films but now I see he also played in Zorba the Greek (film)
What a good gift to your sweet dog Buddy!!What is it made of?Looks very warm!
Well Santa Claus can come whenever he wants ..Over here it is Christmas allover
The passing of one of the great guitar players and composer in U.H ,is sad but so it life.We have to go someday.He left behind him some masterpiece.
I hope all is well(and I see it is)
Thanx for the links to the movie.I take a look at it tonight
Hilsen Norskejenten
Your description of "a little too 'artsy'" for foreign flicks is very accurate for many of them, perhaps even most, I agree, Kelly. I think snobbish and condescending also are words which often can be applied, but there are some true gems and occasional "masterpieces" to brighten the horizon.
I also think most American-made movies are too violent and graphic and made that way by design, but here, too, are found periodic works of art.
Without having seen a specific film, it is difficult to judge it, but movies are like music and books, individuals have to pick and to choose based on their own judgments.
I cannot say lyrics and melodies are of equal importance to me, but being an English major I have to say words have a strong appeal to me and, as much of a reader as you are, I am a bit surprised to see you write that you "rarely pay attention to lyrics."
I will qualify that by saying ridiculous repletion of the same few words usually sends me screaming for an exit. Lyrics I look for are those which require thought and "interpretation," such as Bobby Dylan's "Tangled Up in Blue," or lyrics which are in a very real way poetry, like "I'll Stand by You," written by Billy Steinberg, Tom Kelly and Chrissie Hynde.
Buddy has a new bed which came as the result of flipping a coin several times while attempting to select one from the offerings at Cabela. Actually, it was more complicated than that and he seems to like the end result. Five is the number of the most adult variation of canine household members I have experienced at one time, plus a couple temporary house guests. A German shepherd once gave birth to 13 pups, if you can imagine that .... I will explain it sometime ....
Thank you, Kelly, for coming and for writing a comment. Take care and be safe and .... actually, I think you would like "La Strada" ....
Happy Thanksgiving ....
I like to think I have seen all of Federico Fellini's films, but I am sure if I looked at a list there would be some I did not recognize .... I am sure, however, I have enjoyed all of those that I have seen.
Even after having watched "La Strada," I do not like Anthony Quinn despite the fact I see him as a fine actor. In essence, his role in "La Strada" reinforced my concept of him as a bully and a thug and makes me think of him as a perfect fit for the role. When I think of Quinn in Western movies, it seems to me he usually played a "bad guy." I never have watched "Zorba the Greek," mostly because Quinn is in it and I believe the decision to cast him as Zorba was an error. It was from my perspective, anyway ....
I did read "Zorba" the novel and liked it. Nikos Kazantzakis is a master writer, in my opinion, and has been nominated for the Nobel Prize a number of times. I also have read the Kazantzakis poetic epic, "The Odyssey -- A Modern Sequel," and twice-read his novel, "The Last Temptation of Christ," as well as segments of both books several more times. The film version of "Temptation" did not live up to the book, which is/was not a surprise.
At least one of Quinn's sons was an actor, like his father. Francesco is memorable as one of the primary characters in "Platoon." He died a few years ago.
Buddy's new bed is, and I quote directly: "The rich faux suede is tipped with Berber-fleece accents and sleep surface for warmth. It provides the right amount of comfort and support for any pet. Made of 100% polyester."
Actually, Buddy has a urinary tract infection and is taking anti-biotics at the moment. I had not thought of it before hand, but to take a "critter" to the veterinarian is quite a time-consuming task during this "pandemic era:"
You make an appointment, if you can find a vet actually open for business, drive there, call from the parking lot and wait for a technician to come out to get the pet. Then you wait outside, in your car during this time of the year, until the tech returns with your "baby." The entire process took the better part of an afternoon for me and for Buddy.
By the way, the first words I said to the young lady tech who came to collect Buddy were: "He is girl crazy, so he will love all the attention you give him."
The first words she said to me when she brought him back were: "You were right. He is girl crazy. He loved every minute being in there with us."
I wonder how people with pets which require the services of a vet and who do not have a cell phone and/or a vehicle handle things ....
Thank you, Anita, for coming and for writing a comment. Take care and be safe and .... try not to fall for any of those handsome European actors while you are enjoying your foreign flicks, Norwegian girl ....
Happy Thanksgiving ....
When I was a semi-angst-ridden teenager, I did pay a bit more attention to lyrics and have a notebook somewhere which is filled with song quotes I wanted to remember. (always a treasure when a vinyl LP had lyrics included on the sleeve) These days, I rarely make any effort to decipher lyrics unless it's Contemporary Christian Music. Even then, the tune has to catch me first.
We were at our peak with adult dogs just over a year ago with ten. Seven were outside, three inside. Now it's six outside, and one inside. (we've housed two litters of puppies temporarily, but they don't count) It's never easy to make that decision for them, but I knew it was time last week. Mabel's sister (litter-mate) spared us that burden earlier this summer by dropping dead, literally. A heart attack, evidently. Still.... I miss them both. I have quite a few puppy pictures of them in my earlier blog posts and have enjoyed going back to reminisce. They were part of a litter of twelve that was left in a cardboard box near our mailbox the day after Christmas twelve years ago. There are some pretty sorry folks out there.
I just now read your comment to Anita and I'm sorry to hear about Buddy's infection. Yes.... it's quite a challenge doing "vet things" right now. We've had several experiences over the past eight months, including major surgery for Suzy. We're currently dealing with a major prostate infection for Jed. He's on long-term antibiotics and anti-inflammatory pain medication. I'm hoping that will take care of things. He's been miserable and in much pain. Thankfully, I was allowed to go inside last week (masked, of course) and be with Mabel during her final "procedure".
Back to Buddy.... maybe you could try supplementing him with some cranberry capsules. We had a Rottweiler girl who developed chronic cystitis as a puppy. It wasn't until I started giving her cranberry capsules on a daily basis that she stopped having infections. The vet laughed at me, but hey... it worked. Anytime I'd see her start squatting more often, I'd give her extra and it took care of it. "They" try to say there's no proof that cranberry helps humans with UTIs, that it's just placebo effect, but I cite Esther as my example. She had no idea what she was taking. It just worked.
The reason for my sarcastic remark about first having to find a veterinary office open for business was because Buddy's problem began late one evening. I called our regular "doctor" the next morning when the office opened at 7:00 and was told I could not get him in until 3:00 the following afternoon. It is only a two vet office and one is partially retired, but ....
I called another office with six vets when it opened at 9:00 and was told to bring him in at ten. It was about 3:30 in the afternoon before we made it home.
I cannot imagine what your veterinary bills must be like, Kelly. One of my daughters has been keeping her cat alive with medications for a couple of years. Costs a small fortune ....
Buddy needs a re-check after the anti-biotics are gone. I will take your suggestion and keep cranberry capsules in the medicine cabinet.
Two stories:
When we moved to Dakota, we went with one dog. We rented a house in the country which had a litter of six or seven puppies. I was working at the newspaper and had free classified ads. I said we would keep the pups until they were old enough to leave the mother, then find homes for them. We told our daughter she could pick one to keep. She did. I placed the "free puppies" ad and it ran continually until we had found homes for the rest. While this was going on, occasionally someone would ask us to find a home for their dog and other people would turn their dog loose at the end of the driveway and leave. We actually saw some do that. Eventually, we caught up giving dogs away and I pulled the ad.
At another time in another place, I saw a newspaper ad from a breeder who was giving away young, female, registered German shepherds in exchange for having the dog impregnated and keeping her through the birth of the puppies and until they were old enough to leave her. Then the pups would go back to the original owner. We anticipated three or four pups, and I said yes to the deal. The number turned out to be 13, which sure surprised us and seemed to shock the original owner. Mama and her babies took over the garage and, since it had been my deal, you can figure out who had to keep the garage well cleaned for the next several weeks and how much fun that was .... live and learn ....
I can feel your pain about trying to get Buddy in to the vet in a timely manner. The morning I knew it was time for Mabel I called right when they opened. The person who answered was abrupt, said they were shorthanded, and would see if they could do it. (we've used this clinic since before I was born) She finally came back and said they could do it at 2:45. How about that for making an appointment with death?! At least they didn't charge me for that service. (and honestly they're not an expensive clinic, especially given we don't opt for a lot. More about that another time)
I enjoyed your two puppy stories. Here are mine (one about Alice & Mabel's litter and a couple about MamaDog's):
https://ksrgmck.wordpress.com/2009/01/03/poor-puppies/
https://ksrgmck.wordpress.com/2009/06/18/we-have-puppies/
https://ksrgmck.wordpress.com/2009/07/11/baby-puppies-buppies/
Your "tales" about dogs and puppies made me feel both good and sad. I know you understand what I mean and I do not have to try to explain it.
I am not sure how old I was when I got my first dog, probably somewhere between three and four. I have had one or more with me whenever it has been possible since then. Some have been hunting dogs; some sort of guard dogs; one in particular, a Doberman Pinscher, specifically purchased and formally trained (for a pretty penny, as the idiom goes) as a personal protection dog; but most simply house companions. Each has been special in his or her own way. Two died as I was holding them in my lap.
I think our experiences regarding dogs come down to doing what we believe in our hearts are the right things to do and not especially pause to consider what is practical and what is not.
Again, Kelly, I know you must understand my frame of mind about dogs. Good feelings and sad feelings are the two emotions -- blended with worry and happiness -- most often stirred by the presence of dogs in my life.
Post a Comment