Monday, November 20, 2017

Thanksgiving, road time, religion & music

Jennie A. Brownscombe completed this oil on canvas painting entitled, "The First Thanksgiving at Plymouth," in 1914. Working during the "Colonial Revival Period," Brownscombe chose to include some details that are inconsistent with history, such as the log cabin and the Sioux feather headdress, to symbolize early America. With its elements of religious solemnity, feasting and community, the painting never-the-less had strong emotional appeal to the Americans of one hundred years ago. I wonder if it does today?

Thoughts on religion

I have been attempting to come up with the best word with which to describe myself regarding a certain matter: Excellent .... superb .... preeminent ....

Actually, I suppose any of them or of a dozen others would be sufficient.

Jean-Paul Sarte, in a 1964 autobiography entitled, The Words, wrote this about his grandmother: "She believed in nothing; only her skepticism kept her from being an atheist."

Those words sort of describe me, as well.

As I occasionally mention, I was raised Lutheran. Sometime around age eleven I began to have doubts. In other words, I began to turn into a skeptic about many things, most notably, I suppose, about religion.
 
At age thirteen and one year into the Lutheran confirmation process, I wanted to stop going to church. My mother and I made a bargain -- if I completed the confirmation process, which would be in another year, I would be free to make my own decision. I did complete the process and I did make a decision: I never have been inside a church during a religious service since then other than for weddings and funerals.

Back on point: I believe I am a prince among skeptics and have been searching for the best adjective to use in this regard: An excellent skeptic .... a superb skeptic .... a preeminent skeptic.

The question is, how does one describe a person who does not always believe his own eyes or his own ears, much less the words/thoughts/beliefs of others?

Do not misinterpret my position. I admire and respect and envy individuals who have genuine religious faith. I suppose "faith" is the key word here. Devotion to any religion requires faith, and something within me blocks my ability to have faith in anything and, possibly, faith in anyone. Time will tell in both those regards, I assume ....

The ownership of music

I listen to a lot of music. Mostly classic rock. I usually enjoy "covers" of songs in which other singers and/or bands stage a song originally performed and sometimes composed by another singer/band. There are times, though, when I feel/think/believe no one can do a particular song as well as the original version. A few examples:

The Rolling Stones, it seems to me, "own" the song, Gimme Shelter.
Heart, more specifically, Mary Wilson, "owns" the composition, Alone.
Led Zeppelin, I absolutely know, "owns" the masterpiece, Stairway to Heaven.

Why did I write this ???? I have absolutely no idea other than thinking it might go on for a while. Obviously, it has not and will not .... finis ....

Fram, as a character in a novel

I sometimes think of myself as a fictional character in a novel. That might explain why I write about myself often  -- my thoughts, my beliefs, my experiences. The problem with this habit is that I cannot foresee my ending and, short of a miracle, I will not be able to write about it from the grave. Well, one can always hope for a miracle ....

The voice of Ian Gillan

The music here today begins with a solo by Ian Gillan, the "off-and-on" front man with the "very hard rock" band Deep Purple. The occasion was a 1969 joint appearance of Deep Purple and The Royal Philharmonic Orchestra entitled, "Concerto for Group and Orchestra."

I noted in a previous post that Andrew Lloyd Webber wrote the 1970 rock opera, Jesus Christ Superstar, for Ian Gillan's voice and that Gillan was the first to perform the role of Jesus Christ on the audio album. He does have a marvelous voice. I hope you will agree after listening to this.

Just for the "fun" of it, there is another video included here of Gillan and Deep Purple in the band's usual "heavy, heavy, (heavy, baby)" rock venue. This rendition of Highway Star was performed in 1972. Sort of hard to believe it is the same singer, hah ????

Later, baby ….

I will be "heading out" for a few days on Wednesday morning and absent from the blogs until the following Tuesday. During that time, no posts, no comments, no replies to comments from me. I need a break from the blogs and from the world, and Thanksgiving seems to be a fine time to take one.

By the way, although there will be no religious services involved with this excursion, there will be religious solemnity, and I do intend on enjoying a Thanksgiving feast during my absence -- but, since this is the "Far North," I do not anticipate that it will be outdoors .... short of a miracle ....




10 comments:

Anita said...

Hello and goodmorning USA!

Its a bit sad you are going away for some time..but i quess sometimes we need the solitude..Ilove your post..and specially the painting..love it so much am going to the museums today to get some soul food..
Religion Fram??to live is a religion.Just behave and be good to others --i quess you are promised a place in heaven,,if it excist..
Led Zeppelin.My favourite band when i was young.Also love the song ..Iam gonne leave you baby..
Here in Norway its very cold.Out door activities is now indooractivities.Iam reading.About Anders Behring.The massacre killer worst ever in peacetime in Norway writtten by Åsne Seierstad.She writes damm good.She also has written To sisters.Worst book ever I have read about Syria and the radicalism of young people...
Wish you a happy holiday Fram.Stay safe!

Greetings Anita

Kaya said...

The painting is beautiful, Fram. I have to check on more of Jennie A. Brownscombe's paintings. She was
an interesting artist.

After I read what you wrote about religion and your confession that you are "a prince among skeptics" I thought how does it feel to be a skeptic and enjoy being one. I like that your mother gave you a choice to follow your own path. She was a wise woman!

About religion. I was raised Orthodox but had a difficult time to accept some of rules and dogmas of this religion. I chose to be spiritual instead being religious. Spirituality for me became a way seeking for meaning and purpose and an instinct also what is good and what is bad.

I believe that all religions were formed to respond to that instinct, to know that life has meaning to everything, and to have that childlike like sense of wonder that we are here for some very important purpose of life.

Fram, I wish you a nice and relaxing Thanksgiving. May your break will be wonderful. I hope you will leave behind all your worries and just enjoy this time.

Fram Actual said...

This post looks like one from the "olden days" .... which is to say, long, long, long. I probably would have held back some of the elements if it were not for my planned absence from the blogs. In the past, too, I have done a post on John F. Kennedy. Wednesday will be the fifty-fourth anniversary of his assassination. I had thought about doing one this year, as well, but I will save that until next year .... fifty-five years seems like a more appropriate number.

A week is not long, Anita. It will pass quickly. It will not entirely be solitude for me, either. I plan to pass through Dakota and have Thanksgiving with my son and some of his "associates." Hopefully, the weather will cooperate and we will be able to have a bit of "trigger time," too.

We all have strengths and weaknesses, good points and bad points, and I like to think I follow most of the tenets taught by Jesus although I expect always to be a skeptic regarding his divinity. I am most comfortable with pantheism and deism.

I have a few "favorite" songs, Anita, although a particular singer/band may only have two or three that I listen to frequently. "Stairway to Heaven," by Led Zeppelin, is an absolute masterpiece. It is one of a very, very few that I remember where I was and what I was doing the first time I heard it. "Free Bird," by Lynyrd Skynyrd, is another such song.

The only things I know about Anders Behring Breivik are what I have read/heard in news reports over the years. Since I am curious about individuals such as him, I should get a copy of Asne Seierstad's book. As for me, I have begun to read, "Madonna in a Fur Coat," a novella by Sabahattin Ali. It was written in 1943. He was a young Turk in Berlin in the 1920s and his "madonna" was a cabaret singer. It is billed as a story about love found and love lost.

It has been cold and wet here. Today is cold, but dry enough to work outdoors -- so, that is what I have been doing and it is time to get back at it. The ground probably will have a snow cover when I get back.

I am glad whenever I open my blog and discover you have been here, Anita. Thank you. And, I hope you and Alexander have good days each and every day .... you should find a restaurant that has turkey and pumpkin pie on the menu and have a Thanksgiving dinner on Thursday .... that is what I will be doing .... take care, and see you here and there ....

Fram Actual said...

I more-or-less stumbled into Jennie Brownscombe while looking for a painting appropriate for Thanksgiving. I liked this painting immediately and thought that if I searched every day/all day for a week, I probably would find nothing better suited for my purposes than this one. While it is not historically accurate, the symbolism fits exactly with tradition and the multitude of bright colors show Thanksgiving as a happy, joyous occasion -- which is precisely what I want Thanksgiving to be and I always attempt to make it that way ....

I cannot say that I enjoy being a skeptic. It simply is what I am, who I am, and there is nothing I can do to change it and still remain honest and true to myself. In fact, I am a moody individual and frequently slip into brief moments of depression. I attribute those things largely to my innate skepticism -- they are contributing factors, in the very least. All-in-all, though, I do not think I would choose to be any other way .... while I do not enjoy it, I am content with it.

In my comment to Anita, I wrote this: "We all have strengths and weaknesses, good points and bad points, and I like to think I follow most of the tenets taught by Jesus although I expect always to be a skeptic regarding his divinity. I am most comfortable with pantheism and deism."

Without going into great detail, that is the best I can do at the moment regarding my view about religion in terms of myself. I spent many hours studying religions and debating/arguing them when I was a college boy. I once had a Catholic priest break down into tears and admit there was no way to prove the existence of god and another Catholic priest get up and leave the room when I mentioned the name John Stuart Mill. I might add that I am superstitious and I feel a kinship with the religion/mythology of the "Old Norse." I can explain neither of those factors.

I am not sure how you observe Thanksgiving, Kaya, as a day for just you and your husband or as a day with family and friends, but I assume you will find the occasion to be a welcome break from the turmoil of everyday life during these times. As for me, I will be with my son part of the time which, in itself, will be enjoyable. I also hope the weather will cooperate so I am able to spend a few hours firing a few rifles and a few handguns.

Thank you, Kaya, for coming here and for writing a comment. I enjoy your company and I appreciate learning your views about life and living.

Liplatus said...

I can look at the painting for a long time, a wide range of messages.

Tells about history, but ...
Did the Indians have to eat at the same table?
The Indians became disadvantaged, oppressed.
Maybe still could be true in this dining situation.

The baby bed is unique, cut in half and carved.

It also tells a lot about fashion.
A really awesome and interesting painting.


Evil can also occur in the hiding of religion, although in their own way bad things can be explained by their good intent.
Because of the belief, some wars have arisen.

Honest belief in the heart is the neighbor's love, respect, security, and strength.

It's a refreshing music, but too restless.

Relaxing break for you!

Fram Actual said...

I always have had a tendency to write and to write and then to write some more. When I was a reporter, I had some "intriguing" arguments with editors about what should and should not be cut from a news story; when I became an editor, I finally realized that, in most cases, my arguments had been foolish. Now, I no longer have editors and have forgotten what I learned when I was one in the past -- consequently, I write and I write and what we end up with is a post that goes on and on and ....

Native Americans still are regarded as "second-class citizens" in regions of some Western states, Liplatus, so my assumption is tables for the "white folks" and seated on the ground for Indians is an accurate portrayal. I have lived in Montana and South Dakota and seen for myself the disparity that still exists.

One of my ancestors was a cavalry officer killed by a Sioux and a Cheyenne war party on or about July 2, 1867, in what is now the state of Kansas. I also have relatives who married Indians and, therefore, have mixed-blood second-cousins through their children. One of the children was a Marine killed by "friendly fire" in Iraq. I have written posts about these incidents in the past .... way back when ....

I have no specific knowledge about the origins of baby beds formed from tree trunks, but it is not unusual to see them in photographs of families of white settlers. It seems to me I have seen them in woodcut illustrations, as well, from medieval times in Scandinavian countries. I would imagine they have been around "forever."

I like the painting, too -- very much.

The causes of war are near infinite, I think, and religion is among them. And, I agree, sometimes good intent breeds bad results.

I like what you wrote about neighbors. Being part idealist and part pragmatist, I might add to it a line from the poem, "Mending Wall," by Robert Frost: "Good fences make good neighbors."

I also like your thought about the music .... it is true, but I still thrive from it and it makes me feel alive ....

I am not sure how relaxing my trek will be, but it is certain to refresh my spirit and to put a smile on my face .... speaking of which, as the song lyrics go, now is the time to:

Head out on the highway
Lookin' for adventure
And whatever comes our way ....

Thank you, Liplatus, for your presence and your comment .... I very much appreciate them ....

A Cuban In London said...

Walking shadows indeed, we are, on this grand stage we call life.

Greetings from London.

Fram Actual said...

Greetings, CiL .... as Henry Wadsworth Longfellow wrote in his poem, "A Shadow" ....

Be comforted; the world is very old,
And generations pass, as they have passed,
A troop of shadows moving with the sun;
Thousands of times has the old tale been told;
The world belongs to those who come the last ....

Unfortunately for you and I, it would seem we will not be among the last ....

ANNA said...

Hola gracias por pasar por ya tu blog.
Te deseo feliz Navidad y prospero año nuevo.
Besos.

Fram Actual said...

Thank you, very much, Anna, for your presence here and for your comment. I will be a reflection in the mirror and send you my wish for a Merry Christmas and for a prosperous New Year to you.

I also wish you would open your profile to the public. My middle name should be "curious," as that word describes me well.

Something special ....